(
Adj.) The characteristics consistent with the original
writing and intent of J.R.R. Tolkein and his
works, such as literary Romanticism, poetic dialogue, and characters who believe in a greater good than themselves.
Aragorn: Rings of
Power doesn't feel very Tolkein.
Arwen: Why? It's still about Middle-Earth.
Aragorn: Yes, but the
heroes are depicted as virtuous solely because they believe in themselves, and the narrative seeks to blame
humans for the evils of the Orcs. That's not Tolkein.