Nutter Butter 

When the male ejaculates during a prostate exam. When the male unintentionally busts a nut while at a doctors clinic getting a physical exam.

Bro! The last prostate exam I went to was crazy. As soon as the doctor was knuckles deep in my ass, I couldn't help but nutter butter. It was scary and exciting all at the same time.

Nutter Butter by NewJerzJr March 13, 2024

Peanut Butter Corndog

When You're Having Back Door Adventures and Your Junk Came Out With A Little Nutty Surprise.

Damn !! I was Having Fun with This Girl in Her Doo Doo Maker and my Junk Came Out like a Peanut Butter Corndog

Peanut Butter Corndog by MichaelAmadeus87 March 22, 2024

Peanut butter falcon 

The act of putting your penis in the jar of peanut butter and acting like it is a falcon.

Hey Jenna I pull off a pretty good peanut butter falcon

Peanut butter falcon by fueitbakr April 12, 2024

Amish butter churn

When a wooden handle is inserted rectally, until creamy cum is produced.

Last night Davie used a mop handle to give me an Amish butter churn.

Amish butter churn by SuperFatSteve April 13, 2024

Peanut-Butter Fiesta 

When a group of 4-8 Mexicans gather together and throw their feces in your direction all while yelling various insults.

“Holy crap! I think those guys are starting a Peanut-Butter Fiesta!”

Peanut-Butter Fiesta by Judoka739 April 14, 2024

Squad Butter 

To laugh ferociously at something your good friend Alex said.

L.O.L, LMAO, Squad Butter!

Squad Butter by BaguetteAboutIt April 17, 2024

Ghost Butter Churner 

One man holding a second man’s penis, while a third grasps firmly the first man’s hand creating motion with the first man’s hand.

Rudy really enjoyed Christian’s firm grip from Keith during the Ghost butter churner.

Ghost Butter Churner by Cumguzzler92648 April 24, 2024