butter fairy

a girl that is extremely gorgeous, but won't do anything sexual because she is too religious

john, "hey, Jamie is really hot."

joe, "yea, but you'd never fuck her, she's a butter fairy"

by Andy Land June 27, 2007

fairy butter

The special lube that you use during gay sex after an intense game of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2.

"Yo man, that was a great game of CoD. You should get the fairy butter, I'm feeling extra tight tonight."

by DarkyDook December 6, 2009