There are two elements which comprise the "Fantasy
Football Fair
Trade Rule"
When we look at a
trade, we should (
1) assess whether both teams benefit from the
trade and we should (
2) assess whether the trade is so unfair that it unfairly compromises the integrity of the league.
We need not look to element #2 if the trade does not satisfy element #
1.
Explanation of Element #
1.
Simply consider, do both teams benefit from the trade. Note: Element #
1 does not contemplate whether one team has benefited more than another.
In the likely event of disagreement on this point, the issue is put to a vote. Majority Wins. Tie is
broken by commissioner vote, even if commissioner is involved in the trade (perks of being commissioner).
We need not look to Element #2 if the trade terms do not satisfy Element #
1. If Element #
1 is not satisfied, the trade is vetoed.
Explanation of Element #2:
A trade may unequally favor
one trading party over the other (often this is the case), however, a trade MAY NOT unfairly prejudice the integrity of the league.
We look at whether the trade would - if executed - cause an unfair advantage to either of the parties involved in the trade.
In the likely event of disagreement on this point, the issue is put to a vote. Majority Wins. Tie is
broken by commissioner vote, even if commissioner is involved in the trade.
If Element #2 is not met, the trade is vetoed.
If Element #2 is met, and all parties have voted, then the trade is processed.
FANTASY
FOOTBALL FAIR TRADE RULE ELEMENTS:
To Satisfy Element #
1.
HYPOS:
1. Team
X & Team Z trade. Both teams are made better. Element #
1 is satisfied.
2. Team X & Team Z trade. X is made better but Z remains the same. Element#
1 is not satisfied.
3. Team X & Team Z trade. Both are made worse. Element #
1 is not satisfied.
To Satisfy Element #2:
HYPOS:
1. Team X & Team Z both improve their teams via trade. Team X receives slightly better value than Z. Element #2 is likely satisfied (subject to vote).
2. Same facts, but Team X receives much better value than Z. Element #2 is likely not met (subject to vote).