Buttery Poptart 

A buttery Poptart is when a girl takes a shit, does not wipe, and then gets fucked in the asshole with a lubricated dick, so when the man pulls out, his dick looks like a chocolate poptart with butter on it.

My friend kellen made a buttery Poptart with his girlfriend while Adam watched.

Buttery Poptart by LittleBIGloverX January 24, 2016

Butter your Poptart

After sex, you finish by cumming on her tits.

Once I finish, I’m going to “Butter your Poptart”

Butter your Poptart by Poptartlover574904277266457 October 31, 2022

Butter your poptart

Pub lubricant on your penis

You better butter your poptart before fucking me in the asshole!

Butter your poptart by Butteryourpoptart December 8, 2018

Butter your poptart

Lube your cock

It’s smoother if your butter your poptart first

Butter your poptart by Slick poptart December 8, 2018

butter on a poptart 

The title of Peter Griffin and Glenn Quagmires first song.......seriously look it up tho

Have you ever put butter on a poptart?, it's so freaking good!

butter on a poptart by Black market mouse December 18, 2016