Oh Bethany! Suck my toes!! Share definition Flag When Ryan Simpson and Bethany MacArthur started dating, Sebastien Coyle started moaning this phrase. When Seb saw Ryan he screamed, "Oh Bethany! Suck my toes!!" Oh Bethany! Suck my toes!! by Oh_Oh_Oh_Oh,Ryan September 11, 2018 Get the Oh Bethany! Suck my toes!! mug.