Toilet Butter is made when you piss and shit in a toilet and leave it sitting there so it turns a nasty yellow-orangish looking color, and can sometimes develop a slimy texture.
"Jessica showed me her toilet butter yesterday. It was fucking disgusting!"
by fifthdiamonds September 3, 2018
Get the Toilet Butter mug.
When one rub shit all over the seat of the toilet and someone sits on it
Some put toilet butter on the seat and I got it on my ass
by ethab April 16, 2015
Get the toilet butter mug.