A "why guy" is a guy who questions everything. If you are explaining the most general of detials, he/she will question why. These poeple want you to expound on what you've described, even in the most lame/ pass the time conversations. Dude, you have a college degree, guess that makes up for your lack of common sense and your need to question why.
a question that a good boy has been having for a real long time. even though he's good, he has been bad and it's plain to see. so why do good girls fall in love with him?
"hey, freddie?"
"yeah ricardo."
"why do good girls like bad guys?"
"IVE HAD THAT QUESTION FOR A REAL LONG TIME"
"IVE BEEN A BAD BOY AND ITS PLAIN TO SEE"
"SO WHY DO GOOD GIRLS FALL IN LOVE WITH ME?"