Toe-in-the-butt Share definition Flag A game whereas a son-in-law tries to shove his big toe in the butt cheeks’ of his in-laws. Hey Cheryl, would you like to play Toe-in-the-butt? My big toe needs to fill a hole. Toe-in-the-butt by TITB Reigning Champ February 1, 2022 0 0 Get merch Get the Toe-in-the-butt mug. Buy Now — $32.95 See more merch