When you ejaculate on the outer section of a women's vaginal (the cookie) area so you hopefully won't get her pregnant
Me: Mike, why was Sarah so scared this morning she texted me 12 times asking for you
Mike: I Frosted her cookie last night and now she is worried that she might be pregnant!
Mike: I Frosted her cookie last night and now she is worried that she might be pregnant!
by BigChungus0321 January 1, 2020
Get the Frosted Her Cookie mug.