Rusty trophy : When a girl takes a rather large butt plug in, and as a token of your appreciation, you pull it out and hand it over for her to clean with her mouth.
She gave me a rusty trombone, I had to reciprocate with a rusty trophy.

My good girl deserves a rusty trophy for her obedience.

I got on one knee and handed her her own rusty trophy as a token of my appreciation.
by J.Saint March 30, 2021
Get the Rusty trophy mug.