Pepper the pie

Overdoing something. Going to an extreme. Taking things too far. Good things done to the point where they are no longer good.

You don’t need to pepper the pie; the party will be just fine without the cupcakes.

by EnglishTeaxher September 18, 2022

pepper pie

The act of shaking ones testicles on someone else's steering wheel.

Chad just left me a nice pepper pie bro!

by Glow1996 January 24, 2011