Butter Nutter

Having thick, yellow-ish, unhealthy jizz.

My boyfriend gave me a nasty facial last night and his jizz was all yellow and gross." "He's obviously a Butter Nutter.

Butter Nutter by CottonNuts123 March 23, 2011

Butter Nutter

Using butter for sexual lubricant

I ran out of ky jelly so I broke out the country crock. Nothing like a good butter nutter

Butter Nutter by Joshua Dark June 14, 2020

Butter Nutter

Rama Lynn McClellan

You smell like a Butter Nutter

Butter Nutter by ButterNuttermom April 6, 2023

Plumper Butter Nutter 

Taking the Jizz from a fat person and making a sandwich out of it.

This Plumper Butter Nutter Taste really good with Tuna !!

Plumper Butter Nutter by Awesomeness02 March 3, 2015

Peanut Butter Nutter 

A person who's cum is very thick and heavy

Girl 1: Did you spit or swallow last night?

Girl 2: I spit, he was a peanut butter nutter!

Girl 1: OMG! Hahaha

Peanut Butter Nutter by Mdad September 18, 2016

Nutter Butter 

The equivalent of Swamp Ass on your balls. In other words, it's when your junk is really sweaty.

Dave: Dude, there is a battle going on.

Tony: What?
Dave: Bro, it's Nutter Butter vs. Swamp Ass over the Taint Dome.

Nutter Butter by Trombone73 July 2, 2016

Nashville Nutter Butter

The Nashville Nutter Butter is the action of ejaculating on your partners back in order to create a buttery surface. You then will dump a bucket of popcorn on the lubricated surface to create buttery popcorn. You then finish the act by watching a movie with them while eating the popcorn.

I wanted to try the Nashville Nutter Butter with my girlfriend, but she wasn’t up for it.

Nashville Nutter Butter by Lord WizarD III November 2, 2020