Butterfingers

When someone is fumbling — generally in reference to men;
A lighthearted acknowledgement to a boy that is fumbling;
E.g. Messing up with a great girl they had a chance with. Dropping the ball. Probably repeatedly, and losing their chance with said girl. Losing their shot. Not living up to their potential.

“Hey butterfingers,”
“Okay butterfingers”
female response to a guy that’s been fumbling, messing up, losing his shot. Sometimes as a jest but also acknowledgement he’s fumbling

by Jayfitzgerald February 15, 2026

double butterfinger

The action of finger a girls vagina and asshole using only melted butter as a lube.

My principle gave me a double butterfinger this morning.

by The helpless victim January 12, 2018

spicy butterfinger

A sexual act where chili powder or oil is secretly added to anal lubricant before applying

Mike surprised Denise in the bedroom with a Spicy Butterfinger. She was furious for days

by Chuck Lippincott July 27, 2018

manmade butterfinger

A butterfinger that you've seen made in a factory full of men.

Bro, I just ate a manmade butterfinger, it was so good.

by Pepsicoladelicious February 16, 2023

Tennessee Butterfinger

When you spread peanut butter around her asshole and pussy and she sits in your mouth.

Bob: Dude Jay! My girl just Tennessee Butterfingered me!

Jay: Nice dude! Mine pegged me.

by gamazedz January 31, 2025