Counter Butter 

When a person diarrheas on the counter and a third party rubs their genitals in it, then proceeded by intercourse.

I can't believe they wanted the counter butter on the first date.

Counter Butter by AHamSandwich May 2, 2022

Peanut butter jelly sandwich 

When your girl is on her period so you just put some peanut butter on your dick

“Sorry honey I’m on my period” “it’s ok we can make a peanut butter jelly sandwich”

Peanut butter jelly sandwich by Tittie boi May 5, 2022

its_butters.thats.me 

its_butters.thats.me is a really cool tiktoker who often posts really good content!

"have you followed user its_butters.thats.me?"
"Yes I have! Their really cool aren't they?"
"Mhm!!"

its_butters.thats.me by buttersbiggestfan May 17, 2022

Peanut Butter Box 

When intensely focused on something or talking about something and out if nowhere something out of the blue catches your attention, PEANUT BUTTER BOX.

I was playing catch with my dog and along came a squirrel and, PEANUT BUTTER BOX!

I was telling my girlfriend a story and mid sentence...PEANUTBUTTER BOX!!!!

Peanut Butter Box by BigR3Dd&Poochie May 20, 2022

Peanut butter and jealous 

Something a brown dachshund might say as an insult while in a fight with a yellow cat wearing a pink collar

"Is that what you eat for lunch everyday? A peanut butter and jealous sandwich?"

Peanut butter and jealous by Angel66666 May 22, 2022

Gookie Butter 

Is 5

Gookie butter is 5

Gookie Butter by berkadog123 June 11, 2022

Amish butter 

The result of a handjob continued after orgasm. So-called because of the churned result from a low-technology method.

"Hey Mitch, you're walking kind of funny."
"Yes, I'm a bit sore after making Amish butter last night."

Amish butter by DunkinGas June 25, 2022