square peg round hole Share definition Flag anal fisting. comes from the square knuckle shape of the fist not fitting up the ass my gf is into some really kinky shit. last night she wanted me to square peg round hole her square peg round hole by analplaya2 March 8, 2011 0 0 Get merch Get the square peg round hole mug. Buy Now — $32.95 See more merch