pencil trick 

A magic trick which supposedly makes a pencil disappear into thin air, but actually embeds it into the eye socket of a nearby thug who got a little too close for comfort.

"How about a magic trick? I'm going to make this pencil disappear."

^Typical pencil trick introduction

pencil trick by Midnight Sage August 16, 2008

pencil trick 

n. to slam another's head into an erect pencil causing instant death; form of casual homicide; v. to perform the stated action; made popular by the Joker in "The Dark Knight"

No one volunteered after the pencil trick, so the show ended early and the magician was charged with first-degree murder.

pencil trick by Reid "Mr Peepers" Golden August 23, 2008

Pencil trick 

The short answer to the question "what did you think of the Dark Knight?"

Refers to one of the most memorable moments in the movie.

"Hey, what did you think of the Dark Knight?"
"Pencil trick."

Pencil trick by nighthawk41 March 5, 2009

Thick Pencil 

A fat girl who has no curves but is still to big to wrap your arms around

"Hey man did you see Sam at the party last night?"
"Yeah dude she's a total Thick Pencil"
"Haha Ew"

Thick Pencil by BonnabelShade October 13, 2016

Thick as a first grade pencil 

Curvy, sexy, voluptuous

She's bad! That girl is thick as a first grade pencil

Thick as a first grade pencil by Easyj September 18, 2014