fail gay 

to be unflaboyant or uninitiated in commonly gay convention despite actually being gay

to fail at being gay

"wow.. what a fail gay"

fail gay by Onyx Lioness April 24, 2010

Gay Fail Face 

A face made by a gay guy, usually when taking a photograph, whereas the said gay guy's lips are pooched out in an effort to look like a cracked out model. Possibly inspired by Derek Zoolander's signature pose, Blue Steel.

Oh, Blaine is soooo gay. He has Gay Fail Face in almost all of his Facebook pictures.

Gay Fail Face by GFFblogger March 1, 2010