An expanded model adding two crucial dimensions for finer discrimination. Axis 1: Methodological Soundness (valid methods vs. wishful thinking). Axis 2: Progressive-Stagnant (evolves vs. repeats). Axis 3: Falsifiability-Unfalsifiability (claims can be tested and potentially disproven vs. claims immune to counterevidence). Axis 4: Engagement-Ignorance (engages with scientific community and criticism vs. ignores or dismisses it). These four axes create sixteen positions. Creation science is unsound, stagnant, unfalsifiable (if God can create with apparent age), ignorant (dismisses evidence). String theory is sound, progressive, unfalsifiable (currently), engaged—so it's controversial science, not pseudoscience. The 4 Axes reveal that pseudoscience is defined by clusters of failures, not just one.
The 4 Axes of the Pseudoscience Spectrum "You think astrology is pseudoscience because it's wrong. The 4 Axes show it's deeper: astrology is unsound (anecdote-based), stagnant (same charts for millennia), unfalsifiable (vague predictions), ignorant (no engagement with astronomy). That's four failures, not one. Wrong isn't pseudoscience—refusing to engage with being wrong is."
by Dumu The Void February 25, 2026
Get the The 4 Axes of the Pseudoscience Spectrum mug.