Pathologization of the Sacred
The contemporary replacement for demonization. Where the inquisitor once diagnosed demonic possession, the clinician now diagnoses schizophrenia. Where the Church once performed exorcism, the hospital now performs treatment. Where the institution was the Church, it is now the psychiatric apparatus. The person who hears voices, who sees entities, who experiences the sacred, is not refuted—they are diagnosed; their speech is stripped of authority, their beliefs become symptoms, their demands become expressions of illness. The clinical literature does not support this: the DSM-5 recognizes "Religious or Spiritual Problem" (V62.89) as a non-disorder category, and the ICD-11 moved in the same direction; the criteria for distinguishing non-pathological spiritual experience from psychosis include absence of suffering, absence of impairment, short duration, critical attitude, cultural compatibility, and absence of comorbidities. Hearing voices is not, by itself, evidence of psychosis. Pathologization is therefore not a clinical judgment—it's a rhetorical weapon using psychiatric vocabulary to perform an act of exclusion. The vocabulary changed. The structure didn't.
Pathologization of the Sacred Example: "She told her therapist about her guides, and by session three she had a diagnosis and a prescription. The Inquisition just changed its letterhead."
Pathologization of the Sacred by Abzu Land November 16, 2026