A game in which two or more players take turns sending a photo of a male or female to another player, at which point the receiving player determines whether or not they believe the person in the photo is homosexual. It may or may not be played with a scale of 0-10; 0 being straight, 10 being gay, and anything in between given a description of their level of sexuality.
Bro 1: Hey, wanna play gay or nay?
Bro 2: Sure, bro!
Bro 1: *sends picture of Bro 2*
Bro 2: 0 fer sher.
by NoobTwinz5 July 6, 2012
Get the Gay or Nay mug.
Gay = gay
Fay = Face
Nay = No?
Rosie: No i won't put the pictures up

Emi: :@ you gay fay nay
by Emi B July 11, 2008
Get the Gay Fay Nay mug.