Critical Theory of Neurotheology

The application of Critical Theory to neurotheology—the study of the neurological basis of religious and spiritual experience. Critical Theory of Neurotheology asks: How do cultural assumptions shape which experiences are studied and how they're interpreted? Does neurotheology reduce spiritual experience to brain activity, and what's lost in that reduction? Whose religious experiences are studied, whose ignored? How might neurotheology serve either to explain away or to deepen understanding of spiritual life? It doesn't reject neuroscience but insists that studying the brain basis of spirituality requires attention to context, meaning, and the politics of interpretation.

"They scan meditating monks and find brain changes—therefore spirituality is just brain activity. Critical Theory of Neurotheology asks: 'just'? The brain activity is real, but so is the experience. Reducing one to the other misses the point. Whose experiences get studied? Why monks and not mystics from other traditions? Neurotheology can illuminate or it can reduce. Critical theory insists on asking: what's added, and what's lost, when we look at spirituality through a brain scan?"

Critical Theory of Neurotheology by Abzugal Nammugal Enkigal March 4, 2026