A term used for an individual residing in Brooklyn, who invites a naiive yet attractive date over for a home
cooked meal made with ingredients bought at
local bodegas in hopes of engaging in sexual relations. Post dinner, after the date consents to coitus and without warning, the Brooklynite inserts their index
finger into the rectum of their date, and then yells "Surprise!"
At the college reunion, Lydia gave
Annabel a Bodega Surprise, thus releasing
Annabel's inner sexual tirgress, and solidifying their deep
friendship.