by FatBlackPussyCat December 23, 2012
 Get the nutterbuttermug.
Get the nutterbuttermug. Honey, I would like to slather your thunder thighs with nutterbutter in front of a gay guy, 'cause I'm a devious hetero tease, like a 16 year old cheerleader in a nursing home.Shit!
by bill-muthafuckin green, bitch! November 2, 2003
 Get the nutterbuttermug.
Get the nutterbuttermug. when two homos shave their balls, each take a pat of "Land o' Lakes" butter, melt em down then smear it on their balls, then rub balls with each other.
"Yo I thought Nathan and Jimmy were two straight up dimoldenburgs until I walked in on them doin a nutterbutter...
by cMoney grip January 22, 2009
 Get the Nutterbuttermug.
Get the Nutterbuttermug. Mistakingly thought of as a delectible cookie, it is actually the nasty goop aquired beneath a man's penis and between his nut sack.
Randy scraped off his nutterbutter and spread it upon a piece of bread for his unsuspecting bitch mom to eat.
by cuntpunter69 February 22, 2008
 Get the NutterButtermug.
Get the NutterButtermug. Mistakingly thought of as a delectible cookie, it is actually the nasty goop aquired beneath a man's penis and between his ball sack.
George scraped off his nutterbutter and spread it upon a piece of bread for his unsuspecting bitch mom to eat.
by cuntpunter69 February 22, 2008
 Get the NutterButtermug.
Get the NutterButtermug. A sexual act. Getting your nuts licked after you coat them in warm melted butter and roll them in brown sugar.
by LilMs303 October 28, 2015
 Get the Nutterbuttermug.
Get the Nutterbuttermug. by K A E L I E🔥 October 29, 2019
 Get the Nutterbuttermug.
Get the Nutterbuttermug.