Well polish my nuts and serve me a milkshake Share definition Flag A line from American Pie: The Wedding. It basically means "holy shit, I didn't expect this..." Steve Stiffler: Well polish my nuts and serve me a milkshake! Well polish my nuts and serve me a milkshake by Lemon Duck February 19, 2009 0 0 Get merch Get the Well polish my nuts and serve me a milkshake mug. Buy Now — $32.95 See more merch