An affirmation for when a joking reference is made to something of only moderate popularity, and only when it is presented to a group that was not predictably of the same
fan demographic as the reference itself. Does not apply if the thing being referenced has since
fallen into obscurity due to overuse or otherwise becoming
unpopular.
"The cake is a
lie" stopped being Elite Ball Knowledge after 5 seconds
"Kilroy was here" was Elite Ball Knowledge only among civilians, but lost that status after WW2 shooters got popular and made reference to it
An in-joke exclusively restricted to your friend group will never be Elite Ball Knowledge
2000s-2010s
Era Youtube comments directly quoting something
funny from the very video they're commenting on will never be Elite Ball Knowledge
*Videogame cutscene from perspective of Person
1, who calls up Person 2 for help during a fight*
Person
1: "Oh, you're going into labor right now... can this wait?"
*Some guy in the comments quoting a completely unrelated video from 2 years ago with only a couple hundred thousand views*: "He's pulling the pregnancy card THIS early?!"
*A second commenter responds with a follow-up line from the same referenced video*
*A third commenter*: "Elite Ball Knowledge"
*A kid hears Edgar
Allen Poe's "Tell-Tale
Heart" for the first time, and then responds by quoting the
Spongebob episode "Squeaky
Boots"*: "THEY'RE HERE! UNDER THE FLOORBOARDS!"
*His friend*: "Elite Ball Knowledge"