A nipple that is just bigger in diameter than those small fuckers. They're called cookie nipples because they are usually the size of a cookie.
While comparing nipple colour at my friendsHalloween party, a contest which by they way, I won, I found out that my nipples were larger than those of my friends, who exclaimed: " Cookie Nipples!!"
nipples that are exedingly round, somewhat like a cookie, some, like toni's, are the same color as her tit.
scotty: hey last nite toni got her tits out at the skate park
Gteam: were they good
scotty: no they had cookienipples all: OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wicky: i have no spleen