A form of debunking where the debunking itself relies on assumptions that have been debunked by the very claims being debunked, creating a circular structure. The debunker assumes the falsehood of what they're debunking, uses that assumption to generate debunking arguments, then presents those arguments as proof of falsehood. The circle is invisible to the debunker because their starting assumptions feel like common sense, not like assumptions. Circular Debunking doesn't engage the actual claim—it just performs skepticism within a closed loop that already assumes what it's trying to prove.
Circular Debunking - Debunking in Circles "He debunked spiritual experiences by saying 'they're just brain activity.' But that assumes materialism, which is exactly what spiritual experiences challenge. That's Circular Debunking—using the framework being questioned as the standard for questioning it. The circle is invisible to him because his framework feels like reality. But circular reasoning doesn't become linear just because you're confident."
by Dumu The Void February 28, 2026
Get the Circular Debunking - Debunking in Circles mug.