Amish Moon Butter 

When you piss into someone’s asshole and put your dick in and twist around.

Bro, I just tried Amish Moon Butter with my girl last night! That shit was crazy!

Amish Moon Butter by Certified Idiot May 10, 2023

Amish Moon Butter 

The process of churning piss with your dick, in the ass of Amish-folk.

**Courtesy of GOONS**

Jebediah gave Mary Beth the ol' Amish Moon Butter after last night's sermon.

Amish Moon Butter by MisterGLUb May 10, 2023

Amish Moon Butter 

The act of urinating and thrusting in an Amish person anally while having Intercourse.

"Want to make some Amish Moon Butter?"
"No, we will get caught!"

Amish Moon Butter by BROTUN May 10, 2023

Amish Moon Butter 

When you urinate into a partner's anal cavity, and proceed to use either your genitals or an appropriate tool to stir the liquids inside much like a traditional "churning" motion.

I had to grab my boy Eric the other day and assert authority by giving him the oldAmish Moon Butter.

Amish Moon Butter by Bill Eternal May 12, 2023

Amish Moon Butter 

A sex act where an individual urinates into the anus of an Amish person and then churns it with their phallus

1. Wyd tonight?
2. I'm gonna be making Amish Moon Butter
1. ...

Amish Moon Butter by Secret Spaghetti Locator May 10, 2023

Amish Moon Butter 

The act of peeing into an amish person's ass and then churning it with your cock.

Michael: "Dude i went to the amish market and met this girl."
Rupert: "Oh yeah what was she like, what did yall do?"
Michael: "Oh yea we made some amish moon butter."

Amish Moon Butter by SaturdaySatan May 11, 2023

Amish Moon Butter 

When you pour buttermilk into a person's ass and churn it with your penis

"Honey, the bread is ready. Let's make some Amish Moon Butter with it"

Amish Moon Butter by Tax N Fax May 10, 2023