Definitions by SaturdaySatan

Amish Moon Butter 

The act of peeing into an amish person's ass and then churning it with your cock.

Michael: "Dude i went to the amish market and met this girl."
Rupert: "Oh yeah what was she like, what did yall do?"
Michael: "Oh yea we made some amish moon butter."

Amish Moon Butter by SaturdaySatan May 11, 2023