American Pie Challenge 

You have to masturbate with super glue as lube and try to ejaculate as quick as possible before the glue dries

Man I was trying to do the American pie challenge and now I have a dick in my hand permanently

American Pie Challenge by slumpy4dah2bear0 June 11, 2019

American Pie challenge 

Where you put your dick in a freshly-baked Apple pie like what Jim levenstein did in the 1999 film American Pie.

Matt: "Did you hear what happened to Steve?"

Rob: "No."

Matt: "He did the American Pie Challenge and got hospitalized because of the third-degree burns on his dick."

Rob: "Damn."

American Pie challenge by eyeman69 August 28, 2022

American Pie Shower Challenge 

American Pie Show Challenge can be defined as showering in the time of the song American Pie by Don McLean. The goal is to wash and shave everything in as fast as you can before the song American Pie is finished.

I just completed the American Pie Shower Challenge in 7 minutes 30 seconds, WITH extra shaving!

American Pie Shower Challenge by The Squid February 26, 2022