A Buffalo Nickel 

A shitty hand-job performed for the price of $5 USD.

He was a catch, but all I got was a Buffalo Nickel.

A Buffalo Nickel by notorious otter April 27, 2022

Rusty Buffalo 

Donut Operator thinks it is a thing and he was right.

"the ol rusty buffalo, sounds like something on the urban dictionary"

Rusty Buffalo by jaquavywavy August 13, 2022

Mexican Buffalo

Anal sex with your significant other on Wednesday night after they had taco Tuesday and wing Wednesday.

Hump day is always more special when it ends with a Mexican Buffalo!

Mexican Buffalo by Bigjohncal October 5, 2022

bloody buffalo 

The act of masturbating with your hairbrush while menstruating.

When that time of the month came, Becky went through so many hairbrushes making bloody buffalos.

bloody buffalo by Stihigh80 October 22, 2022

New Buffalo Steamer 

That thing when you're driving eastbound on I-94 and you upper-decker the toilet at the Michigan Welcome Center

There wasn't a toilet for fifty miles so I dropped a New Buffalo Steamer while I read the Four Winds Casino pamphlet.

New Buffalo Steamer by ruenix February 25, 2023

Brass Buffalo 

Similar to a brass monkey - the brass buffalo is a beverage made by taking several sips of beer and then mixing in several squirts of Heinz yellow mustard into it. It originated on nut farms in the countryside of the pacific northwest and is considered a delicacy.

Bro, pass the Heinz lets make some brass buffalos

Brass Buffalo by NiceFeet95 March 19, 2023

Reverse Buffalo Bill 

When a dude is sitting on a small toilet seat and has to pull his twig and berries forward so they don’t fall in the toilet bowl while he’s taking a shit.

Mike had to Reverse Buffalo Bill himself so he could use the toilet on the houseboat.

Reverse Buffalo Bill by Rhinoceros Honches May 28, 2023