Amish Butt Butter

1. For extreme Amish- pouring milk into a female's ass then fucking the ass with a corn cob until butter is formed 2. For the liberal Amish- putting milk in a female's ass then pounding that shit until you churn out some good 'ole Amish Butt Butter.

After pouring milk into Catherine's anus, Jedediah churned some Amish Butt Butter last night while butt fucking her.

by Bhaggard December 18, 2008

amish moon butter

When one urinates into an Amish persons anal cavity

“Damn I love it when my Amish girl friend lets me make some of that Amish Moon Butter.”

by Goon Fiend May 10, 2023

Amish moon butter

Peeing in a girls ass, and churning it out.

Girl, tonight I'd love to make some Amish moon butter with you!

by GoonFunnyMoment May 11, 2023

Amish moon butter

When you piss into someone’s ass and then churn it with your dick.

TheDoo watched excitedly as Ethan made Amish moon butter with a hobo.

by Hobo toucher May 11, 2023

Amish Moon Butter

When you piss into an Amish persons ass and then you churn it with your dick

I want some goddamn Amish Moon Butter.

by mynamebruh May 10, 2023

Amish Moon Butter

The act if urinating in an amish persons rectal cavity and churning the urine with your penis, as if it were butter.

Hey man! I have a throbbing UTI because I just finished giving Debby the craziest Amish Moon Butter. My dick was literally churning my own piss in her ass! It was awesome!

by Oscarsom Tabington May 10, 2023

Amish Moon Butter

The sexual act of pissing in an Amish person's ass, and churning it with your penis.

I went to Pennsylvania and had me an Amish Moon Butter last night.

by Bob_Da_Bes May 11, 2023