Top definition
1. For extreme Amish- pouring milk into a female's ass then fucking the ass with a corn cob until butter is formed 2. For the liberal Amish- putting milk in a female's ass then pounding that shit until you churn out some good 'ole Amish Butt Butter.
After pouring milk into Catherine's anus, Jedediah churned some Amish Butt Butter last night while butt fucking her.
by Bhaggard December 10, 2008
Get the mug
Get a Amish Butt Butter mug for your friend Nathalie.