Nutter Butter 

When a guy nuts in a jar of peanut butter, while lying in a bathtub.

"When we asked if he really fucked a jar of peanut butter, he replied 'Yes, I bought it myself.'"
"Wow, he actually did a full-on nutter butter."

Nutter Butter by UwU, not OwO June 27, 2020

nutter butter 

When one ejaculates into anothers anus..

bob nutter buttered betty so she wouldn't get pregnant.

nutter butter by Dick Lea May 10, 2011

Nutter Butter 

dried up, nasty ass moldy cum.

Dude, you got some nutter butter on your pants!

Nutter Butter by Live!Laugh!Love! April 14, 2009

Nutter butter 

A crazy or wildiy odd Gay man or woman

A gay friend of mine likes to jack off while his dog licks his ass crack, therefor he is a nutter butter. He is crazy

Nutter butter by Alex cooper January 9, 2008

Nutter Butter 

When one unspecified person kicks a man in the ass at the same time that another unspecified person kicks a man in the junk, thus creating a sort of "nut sandwich" between their feet.

We gave Raffael a wicked nutter butter because he stole our pizza!

Nutter Butter by K. Rain January 25, 2008

nutter butter 

when one "busts a nut" in a girls butt. May be associated with a creampie, but used exclusively when talking about the ass.

GUY1: yo dude, so how was it last night?
GUY2: it was alright man, I'm kinda embarrassed though
GUY1: why's that?
GUY2: I don't know, I accidently came inside her ass
GUY1: oh that's nothin bro... I gave my girlfriend a nutter butter last night as well

nutter butter by bigboy234175 April 25, 2009

nutter butter 

using peanut butter as wang lube

oh diane! my wang! get creamy next time, the chunky hurts too much when we do it but ill make it creamy soon

nutter butter by michael niktaris March 30, 2004