Having someone complete the act of masturbation by pulling up and down on the forearm, while the male holds his own penis. This can be done with an infinite number of males. If and when someone ejaculates, it must be done onto a
single Nutter
Butter. The last person to
orgasm must eat this cookie, thus becoming a Brudder for life.
Fraternity initiates; Sam, Dave, Diego, Bill, Steve, and
Rod all pair off and begin the Dutch Rudder Nutter
Butter Brudder challenge, Bill lost and now must eat the Nutter
Butter. Bill is definitely a Brudder.