The act of taking a dump in between two Graham crackers, cumming on the poop, and making the other person eat it
by Pecker Abu Bakr August 5, 2020
Get the Cleveland Nutter Butter mug.Having someone complete the act of masturbation by pulling up and down on the forearm, while the male holds his own penis. This can be done with an infinite number of males. If and when someone ejaculates, it must be done onto a single Nutter Butter. The last person to orgasm must eat this cookie, thus becoming a Brudder for life.
Fraternity initiates; Sam, Dave, Diego, Bill, Steve, and Rod all pair off and begin the Dutch Rudder Nutter Butter Brudder challenge, Bill lost and now must eat the Nutter Butter. Bill is definitely a Brudder.
by Dingus McBerry Johnson July 25, 2021
Get the Dutch Rudder Nutter Butter Brudder mug.Once a man is close to ejaculation. He pulls out and sticks his penis in a tub of butter. Then inserts his penis in a woman's rectums and finishes.
by Pinkt@c0 October 11, 2010
Get the Peruvian Nutter Butter mug.by A.M. Magicman, K. Swizort December 30, 2008
Get the Indiana Nutter Butter mug.When you get two guys and cover them from head to toe with peanut butter, and than procede to vigorously nut all over them and than lick everything off at the end.
by JamesNewton February 4, 2025
Get the Nebraskan Nutter Butter mug.The act of sticking your finger in your ass and pulling it out to find cum and nutty filled shit on your fingers. Then proceeding to stick them in your partners mouth
My dad gave me a raging new york nutter butter last night. or my grandmothers new york nutter butter taste the best
by DonkeyMcPunch July 1, 2024
Get the New York Nutter Butter mug.The act of inserting heavy cream into ones anus and a man churning it with his penis until he ejaculates.
by Theodore Foreskin July 5, 2025
Get the New England Nutter Butter mug.