The act of anal sex while in the missionary position. Since the penetrating party must “reach around” the vaginal area of the other participating party, the name is a given.
Bill: Oh, that girl loves it in the ass...
Matt: But I heard she’s a total starfish.
Bill: I just had to reach around the pie.
Matt: But I heard she’s a total starfish.
Bill: I just had to reach around the pie.
by PieReacher January 10, 2018