Top definition
Clothes from American Eagle that you don't buy because they don't fit or you don't like them. Based off of the band, "The All-American Rejects"
Vicky- So did you buy that green sweater?

Sandy- No, it ended up being an All-American Eagle Reject.

Stacy- Those clothes are All-American Eagle Rejects, can you go put them back?

Leah- Sure thing.
by Nancy Drew 5000 September 04, 2009
Get the mug
Get a All-American Eagle Rejects mug for your fish Sarah.