by A.M. Magicman, K. Swizort December 31, 2008
When you take a used condom and put a straw in it then put it back in a drink and offer it to someone.
by Silly Goose 2010 February 15, 2010
by Drugs are bad for you February 01, 2017
Having someone complete the act of masturbation by pulling up and down on the forearm, while the male holds his own penis. This can be done with an infinite number of males. If and when someone ejaculates, it must be done onto a single Nutter Butter. The last person to orgasm must eat this cookie, thus becoming a Brudder for life.
Fraternity initiates; Sam, Dave, Diego, Bill, Steve, and Rod all pair off and begin the Dutch Rudder Nutter Butter Brudder challenge, Bill lost and now must eat the Nutter Butter. Bill is definitely a Brudder.
by Dingus McBerry Johnson July 26, 2021
It's when you wipe your ass from back to front while brushing the shit filled toilet paper against your nut sack. This will leave a decent amount of feces on your sack and in your ball hair. You then proceed to find a nasty whore that doesn't mind having a shit smeared ball sack dunked in her filthy mouth. "hence a nutter butter tea bag".
by Peanut butter bar February 22, 2014
by 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀😭💀 September 18, 2023
My boyfriend gave me a nasty facial last night and his jizz was all yellow and gross." "He's obviously a Butter Nutter.
by CottonNuts123 March 08, 2011