Also known as SML Critic is someone who has a massive vendetta on a youtube puppet show. They have the inability to move on and accept that the show will never be as good as it used to be. They are among the biggest hypocrites in the fandom because of the fact that spend time whineing about how "toxic" the community is when they are usually play a big role in it by sending death threats to fans who are under the age of 18 and unnecessary personal shots to like "Your parents must of failed you kid" Reeeee I'm going a grown up fat man who can't control his own emotions. A lot of these SML Boomers turn out to Pedophiles as well. What were the odds.
Some SML Reviewers even make their own puppet shows that are worse than the product they complain about. They have no passion/creativity because hate, spite, and negativity has consumed them into keeping them in the same circle jerk elitist bubble.
by Rural Encyclopedia June 22, 2025

The sml (super mario logan) effect is a process in which a cast made of non original characters are slowly replaced by original characters resembling the cast. Noteable examples include SML and SMG4.
by LebanonFrames April 16, 2023

Aka SML Reviewer, Old SML Fanboy, or SML Boomer is a lonely male adult virgin usually in the millennial or Gen Z demographic. Who does nothing but complain and make boring lazy reviews about an internet puppet show named SML. These criticisms are always the exact same thing and can always be summed up as "Old SML good, Modern SML bad". They have yet to grow up and for some reason are unable to grow up past their plush cooming phase. They can't accept that the old version of the show will never return, and will constantly grift on the massive hate train of the modern show. They are entitled set of elitists who thinks they are opinions are more superior than anyone else in the community. Jeffy has been used as a massive scapegoat on why Modern sml "sucks" and have tried massive campaigns to axe the character even though he's the sole reason the channel became super popular in the first place. Some critics have even "threatned" to leave even though they are no threat and usually the ones that quit comeback like a month later. They take the show way too seriously. They even go as far into thinking they have some platonic relationship with the creators even though it's very obvious he doesn't give a crap about them and a few dared called "evil" because of his greed even though a lot of reviewers are no better than him. They can be Pedophiles and absolute creeps.
P.S: The community is also filled with virtue signaling hypocrites who suffer from TDS.
P.S: The community is also filled with virtue signaling hypocrites who suffer from TDS.
SML uploaded!?!? Time to leave a dislike and write a Bible sized comment on why this video sucked!!!!!! Wow an SML Critic is very similar to a Pro Smash Bros. Player and a Disney Adult! Whats up with these Nintendo related communities being so unhinged?
by Rural Encyclopedia June 21, 2025

by FilipinoRizzler March 24, 2024

Sml that was funny
by Xanny4dani May 1, 2024

Person 1: SML Never Disappoints ❤️
Person 2: SHUT THE FUCK UP I DON'T GIVE A SHIT STOP SAYING THAT YOU ABSOLUTE BUFFOON
Person 2: SHUT THE FUCK UP I DON'T GIVE A SHIT STOP SAYING THAT YOU ABSOLUTE BUFFOON
by RackaRabbid April 4, 2023

Short for Smith Mountain Lake, a tourist destination in the Roanoke River Valley. Often printed on T-shirts and other Smith Mountain Lake Souvenirs.
by Alligator King July 8, 2021
