New York Nutter Butter

The act of sticking your finger in your ass and pulling it out to find cum and nutty filled shit on your fingers. Then proceeding to stick them in your partners mouth

My dad gave me a raging new york nutter butter last night. or my grandmothers new york nutter butter taste the best

by DonkeyMcPunch July 1, 2024

Peanut Butter Nutter

A person who's cum is very thick and heavy

Girl 1: Did you spit or swallow last night?

Girl 2: I spit, he was a peanut butter nutter!

Girl 1: OMG! Hahaha

by Mdad September 18, 2016

Nutter butter

What you’re called when you cum in a girl’s mouth and she pukes from it

That’s nutter butter. His poor girlfriend had to taste that

by Iamnotnotreal May 15, 2019

Nutter Butter’d

Running someone over in GTAV with your car at extremely high speeds.

“Oh god please don’t Nutter Butter’d me I’m begging you.” “I just Nutter Butter’d Hayden, oh my lord.”

by Akero_ March 27, 2022

Nutter butter

The act of inserting ones own balls into thine own or your lovers own butthole

Im gonna go home nutter butter myself and the cry myself to sleep

by Chicken_enthusiast October 3, 2018

Nutter by BAE

Too slap the inners of the glory hole with ones nutsack.

Steve gave Ben a look that suggests he is about to get a Nutter by BAE on the trails later.

by Definition by BAE February 22, 2022

New England Nutter Butter

The act of inserting heavy cream into ones anus and a man churning it with his penis until he ejaculates.

“Me and Chris made some New England Nutter Butter last night!”

by Theodore Foreskin July 5, 2025