Wordplay on the band "Sugar Ray", which Mark McGrath was the lead singer of. He had a homophobic meltdown a few years ago when a teenage boy called him "Sugar Gay." Grath's fragile masculinity was really insulted by the juvenile insult so he started screaming back threats and insults.
Friend: "Man, what happened to that guy from Sugar Ray?"

You: "You mean Mark McGrath? More like Sugar Gay, haha."

Mark McGrath: "WHO THE FUCK SAID THAT? I WILL BEAT THE FUCK OUT OF YOU. I WILL FUCK YOUR DICK OFF. GO TWEEZE YOUR NIPPLES, BRO!!!"
by thejolama February 22, 2018
Get the sugar gay mug.
When u have a gay car and your sugar gay
Ned marshall is sugar gay
by olivia da squish May 22, 2020
Get the sugar gay mug.
Deputy Ryans pop. Also his nickname
Up in the sky! It's a bird! It's a plane! No it's the Gay Sugar Daddy! Suck on dis caulk bois !
by spazz13 November 5, 2004
Get the Gay Sugar Daddy mug.
if you were green hoodies on Mondays, you are surely sugar gay
Look at Sofus, wearing a green fxcking hoodie. He’s sugar gay dude.
by Smexy Tiger December 6, 2021
Get the sugar gay mug.