A thick curdled residue found in equine semen harvesting gear. True pony yogurt develops after semen harvesting equipment is used many times without being cleaned.
Rancher 1: Hot damn! What is that smell?
Rancher 2: Aw, that's just Jeanine. She finally got around to cleaning that horse cock sleeve and now she's got pony yogurt up to her elbow!
Rancher 2: Aw, that's just Jeanine. She finally got around to cleaning that horse cock sleeve and now she's got pony yogurt up to her elbow!
by tupac_lives July 22, 2016

by Drinkydadjimbo February 1, 2023

by Ma Nigga Sakeen Alib Talib June 10, 2014

by mechanicalgroundmark February 28, 2023

When a guy cums so much and so often it resembles a serving of yogurt. Can be served plain or with fruit.
by MissKB April 6, 2014

by Froman B May 16, 2011

by TylerLikesSpecialYogurt October 25, 2009
