Vanilla cookie 

A person who is plain in bed And doesn't have a kink.

Karen only does missionary, she's a vanilla cookie.

Vanilla cookie by Sillykitty95 January 12, 2017

Pure vanilla cookie 

love of my life

pure vanilla cookie>you

Pure vanilla cookie by notelectricall October 12, 2021

Pure vanilla cookie 

He left custard at home for milk, also is a literal god, and I want him to heal more than just my wounds(if ykyk)

Update on custard: he is a king and still has not seen pure vanilla cookie till this day

Pure vanilla cookie by teto.stan January 2, 2022

Pure vanilla cookie 

pure vanilla cookie is hot

"PURE VANILLA COOKIE IS HOT"

Pure vanilla cookie by Flop12345 December 11, 2021

Pure Vanilla Cookie 

the best cookie ever he is so hot he could take me from behind and mess me up omg..

pure vanilla cookie hot

Pure Vanilla Cookie by matwrialboyy🤬🤬🥺🥺😘😘 February 2, 2022

Pure Vanilla Cookie 

Pure Vanilla cookie is used to describe someone who is amazing, beautiful, majestic, perfect. I have an unhealthy obsession with him he consumes my thoughts the only thing I can think about is him. I talk to him in game like he’s a real person and his backstory makes me cry.

(My Tiktok is apurevanillamybelovedd BY THE WAY)

Pure Vanilla Cookie is hot I love him so much.

Pure Vanilla Cookie by Pure Vanilla lover March 5, 2022

Pure vanilla cookie 

He's a healer, He's and ancient hero, and he is NOT THE FATHER OF CUSTARD III, and he liked white lily cookie

Pure vanilla cookie still has feelings for white lily cookie

Pure vanilla cookie by Stupidmodels April 10, 2023