Cookie mush is when Pisstner puts what shes grateful for on her thanksgiving list and we all convince her it's something bad.
Pisstner: "I'm gonna make cookie mush"
Ives and I: oh my god pisstner you dont even know what that means!
Ives and I: oh my god pisstner you dont even know what that means!
by Hondacf100! November 16, 2025
Get the cookie mushmug.