A fight about the fight—a conflict over how to interpret, validate, or conduct the scientific process itself. It's a dispute one level above the science, often between philosophers, sociologists, and reflective scientists. The topic isn't a fact about nature, but a fact about how we know facts about nature.
Theory of Metascientific Dispute Example: The replication crisis in psychology sparked a metascientific dispute. The fight isn't about a specific psychological theory, but about the validity of statistical methods (p-hacking), publication bias, and the very integrity of the scientific process in that field. It's a crisis of methodology, not of mind.
by Abzugal Nammugal Enkigal February 6, 2026
Get the Theory of Metascientific Dispute mug.