Top definition
When you just straight up shove a Nutter Butter® candy bar right up your ass while you scream out "Give me the cream!" and cum all over the floor.

"Nutter" refers to you cumming, "in the Butter" refers to anal stimulation with a Nutter Butter®
Oh man, Chad, I had the BEST Nutter in the Butter last night. You gotta try a Nutter in the Butter. You will not believe the sensation.
via giphy
by nutterinthebutter July 29, 2018
Get the mug
Get a Nutter in the Butter mug for your Facebook friend José.