Nutter in the Butter

When you just straight up shove a Nutter Butter® candy bar right up your ass while you scream out "Give me the cream!" and cum all over the floor.

"Nutter" refers to you cumming, "in the Butter" refers to anal stimulation with a Nutter Butter®

Oh man, Chad, I had the BEST Nutter in the Butter last night. You gotta try a Nutter in the Butter. You will not believe the sensation.

by nutterinthebutter July 30, 2018

Butter Nutter

Using butter for sexual lubricant

I ran out of ky jelly so I broke out the country crock. Nothing like a good butter nutter

by Joshua Dark June 15, 2020

Plumper Butter Nutter

Taking the Jizz from a fat person and making a sandwich out of it.

This Plumper Butter Nutter Taste really good with Tuna !!

by Awesomeness02 March 03, 2015

Nutter Butter Stutters

When somebody goes on a streak of stutters while talking or chokes under pressure during a game.

Billy was doing great during his presentation until the Nutter butter stutters got to him.

by WeUsedToPlayHouse April 13, 2022

New York Nutter Butter

The act of sticking your finger in your ass and pulling it out to find cum and nutty filled shit on your fingers. Then proceeding to stick them in your partners mouth

My dad gave me a raging new york nutter butter last night. or my grandmothers new york nutter butter taste the best

by DonkeyMcPunch July 02, 2024

Butter Nutter

Rama Lynn McClellan

You smell like a Butter Nutter

by ButterNuttermom April 07, 2023

Nutter Butter

A man who never uses a condom and uses women as a semen dispenser.

That kid Aaron is a nutter butter, be careful you might get pregnant from him.

by angsiga21 March 31, 2019