When you just straight up shove a Nutter Butter® candy bar right up your ass while you scream out "Give me the cream!" and cum all over the floor.
"Nutter" refers to you cumming, "in the Butter" refers to anal stimulation with a Nutter Butter®
"Nutter" refers to you cumming, "in the Butter" refers to anal stimulation with a Nutter Butter®
Oh man, Chad, I had the BEST Nutter in the Butter last night. You gotta try a Nutter in the Butter. You will not believe the sensation.
by nutterinthebutter July 30, 2018
by Joshua Dark June 15, 2020
by Awesomeness02 March 3, 2015
Girl 1: Did you spit or swallow last night?
Girl 2: I spit, he was a peanut butter nutter!
Girl 1: OMG! Hahaha
Girl 2: I spit, he was a peanut butter nutter!
Girl 1: OMG! Hahaha
by Mdad February 12, 2016
by Cretioon September 2, 2021
Th act of fucking girl in her pussy until you're about to explode your load. You then pull out and stick it in her ass and blow your load. Nutter buttering.
I had this freaky girl that had me nutter buttering her
by The name is Jefe October 6, 2019