Nutter Butter 

When a girl shits on a man’s penis and he then precedes to bust a load into the girls booty

After Michael gave Allie a nutter butter, she went home to shower off the mixture of jizz and shit

Nutter Butter by Sexpun November 14, 2019

Nutter Butter 

When you send each other your nudes.

Hey dude wanna be Nutter Butters? I'll send mine first.

Nutter Butter by alligatormater123 October 13, 2020

Nutter Butter 

It's the mucous mixed with spunk after your remove your junk from another orifice, animal or human.

Yo, I had some nutter butter on my jawn after I took it out of her ass.

Nutter Butter by S. Leopoldo Pennauchi November 6, 2020

Nutter Butter 

The built up mixture of piss, nut and other bodily fluids under the foreskin of a penis. It can be enjoyed on toast with spices such as salt and paprika. Funnily enough, prime untouched Nutter Butter can be sold at a high price to certain individuals.

"Damn man, since I've become vegan, I can't have dairy and shit like that." "Yo you should try Nutter Butter dude, it can be grown easily by yourself and it isn't cruel to any animals!"

Nutter Butter by PoggersTesties February 22, 2021

Nutter Butter 

When she smashes your balls so hard they turn into a fine paste, almost butter-like.

Guy 1: BROOOO WTF HAPPENED TO YOU!!!!

Guy 2: LAST NIGHT I GOT NUTTER BUTTERED SHIT BUSSIN!!!!!!!!!!!

Nutter Butter by A gun to ma YEET May 6, 2021

Nutter butter 

A nutter butter is almost like lube but made out of butter it is applied when you're about to have intercourse.

Wait let me apply some nutter butter.

Nutter butter by Kingsyrup February 17, 2022

Nutter Butter 

The act of filling a girls asshole with peanut butter, then nutting in it repeatedly until her ass is stuck shut

Husband: I love nutter butters
Wife: Oh like the cookie?
Husband: No babe, grab the peanut butter and I’ll show you

Nutter Butter by I Made This Account In Spite April 30, 2022